What do we actually do when the house is burning and the arsonists are organized?
There comes a moment in every crisis when analysis must become strategy. When understanding the fire is no longer enough—you need to know where to stand, what to carry, and how to keep breathing through the smoke.
We have spent this dialogue tracing the deep roots of America's present rupture: the 1,500-year tension between Roman universal law and Germanic tribal loyalty, the recurring eruption of the chieftain every century, the unique position of Black Americans who learned to lean on the Roman promise as a shield against tribal cruelty. We have named the machinery of closed epistemic systems, the impossibility of reasoning with those inside, the madness of watching hypocrisy celebrated as virtue.
But now comes the question that matters most:
What do we actually do?
Not in theory. Not in hope. In practice. On the ground. With limited options and real danger.
The answer breaks into two fronts, and both are essential:
1. Keep the movement from growing. (Containment, disruption of recruitment)
2. Withstand the encroachment over time. (Resilience, endurance, protection)
Let's walk through both.
PART ONE: Keeping the Movement from Growing
You cannot reason someone out of a closed system. But you can interrupt the pathways by which the system recruits and retains members.
1. Disrupt the Recruitment Pipeline
The movement grows by pulling in the disaffected—the lonely, the economically anxious, the culturally disoriented. It offers them belonging, meaning, and an enemy. The only thing that defeats a counterfeit community is a real one.
Practical moves:
· Be present in vulnerable spaces. Not to argue politics, but to offer genuine connection. Mutual aid groups, community gardens, parent networks, neighborhood associations. The movement offers a fake belonging. Offer the real thing.
· Name the bait-and-switch publicly. When "family values" imagery is used, say plainly: "They talk about protecting families while supporting policies that gut schools, deny healthcare, and impoverish working parents. The image is not the agenda." Keep it short, repeatable, true.
· Support organizations that help people leave. Groups that deprogram high-control group members exist. They need funding, visibility, and connections to those trying to exit MAGA. This is long-term extraction work.
2. Make Tribal Loyalty Costly
The movement's power comes from making loyalty cheap and socially rewarded. Raise the cost.
Practical moves:
· Public accountability at the local level. Record school board meetings, city council sessions, public comments. When tribal rhetoric is deployed, put it on the record. Not to shame individuals into changing, but to make affiliation visible and documented. This matters for history and for deterrence.
· Strategic economic consequences. Consumers can choose where to spend. Businesses that openly support the movement can be noted. Boycotts are a traditional tool. Use them sparingly, legally, and with clear goals.
· Refuse normalization in your own circles. In your spaces, do not pretend. Do not "both sides" the obvious. Make it clear that this ideology is not acceptable. Silence in the face of cruelty is complicity.
3. Starve the Narrative Ecosystem
The movement runs on a closed information loop—Fox, Newsmax, podcasts, algorithm-driven rage. You cannot shut it down, but you can starve its spread into uncommitted spaces.
Practical moves:
· Support local journalism. The movement thrives on the death of local news, which leaves people dependent on national tribal sources. Fund, subscribe to, amplify local reporters who cover actual community issues.
· Create alternative content. The right dominates podcasts and YouTube because they showed up. Make good information free, accessible, and engaging. Meet people where they are.
· Flood the zone with reality, quietly. Not arguing. Just existing. Share stories of actual people, actual consequences, actual policy outcomes. Let reality do the slow work.
4. Target the Next Generation
Young people are less locked in. They inherit the world the movement is breaking.
Practical moves:
· Support media literacy education. Not "both sides" journalism class, but actual training in how to identify propaganda, closed loops, and emotional manipulation.
· Be the sane adult. If young people are in your life, be someone they can ask questions without lectures. Model thinking, not just conclusions.
· Fund youth programs that build actual skills and community. The movement offers identity. Offer something better: competence, friendship, purpose, and the tools to think for oneself.
PART TWO: Withstanding the Encroachment Over Time
This is the harder front. This is survival while the fire burns. Options are few, but they exist.
1. Build Physical and Psychological Safety Nets
The state may not protect you. Federal law may not reach you. Local authorities may be hostile. You must build what the system no longer provides.
Practical moves:
· Know your neighbors. Not the ones with flags, but the ones who share your reality. Build a contact tree. Know who has medical training, who has a truck, who has a basement, who has skills you might need. This is basic community preparedness.
· Create mutual aid networks. Food, childcare, transportation, small loans. When systems fail, people need each other. Build those relationships now, before crisis hits.
· Secure your documents. Passports, birth certificates, property records. Have a go-bag if you're in a high-risk area. Hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
· Prioritize mental health. This is not luxury; it's survival. Find your people. Find your outlet. Do not carry this alone. The movement wants you exhausted and isolated. Refuse that gift.
2. Document Everything
The gray rock strategy does not mean blindness. It means watching, remembering, and recording.
Practical moves:
· Keep records. Incidents of harassment, policy changes, official misconduct. Dates, names, screenshots. Use encrypted storage if needed.
· Support legal funds. Organizations like the ACLU, NAACP Legal Defense Fund, and local immigrant rights groups need money to fight the slow war of attrition in the courts.
· Build relationships with real journalists. Not pundits, but reporters who cover extremism, civil rights, and local government. Be a source. Help them see what's happening on the ground.
3. Build Parallel Power
If the state is captured, you need institutions the state cannot easily touch.
Practical moves:
· Support Black-led institutions. Historically Black colleges, community development corporations, credit unions, churches. These have survived every American era. They will survive this one.
· Create cooperative economics. Food co-ops, buying clubs, shared childcare, skill-sharing networks. Reduce dependency on systems that may fail or turn hostile.
· Invest in education outside the system. Homeschool networks, freedom schools, apprenticeships. Not to isolate, but to ensure the next generation is educated regardless of what happens to public schools.
4. Practice Strategic Non-Engagement
This is the gray rock in action. You cannot fight every battle. You will burn out.
Practical moves:
· Choose your fights. Not every provocation deserves a response. Ask: Does engaging this help my community survive? Does it protect anyone? Does it build anything? If not, let it pass.
· Refuse the performance. The movement wants your fear, your anger, your tears on camera. Deny them. Save your emotion for your people, your energy for your work, your passion for what you build, not what you oppose.
· Hold space for those who leave. When someone breaks from the tribe, they are shattered. Be ready to catch them without judgment. This is how the movement shrinks—one person at a time, in silence, in safety.
The Long Game: What We're Actually Building
Here is the distillation of everything we have discussed:
We are building an ark while the flood rises.
We cannot stop the flood by arguing with the water. We can:
· Warn people away from the rising tide.
· Build vessels for those who will need them.
· Document the storm for those who come after.
· Protect as many as we can, for as long as we can.
· Ensure that when the water recedes, there is something left to rebuild.
This is not the work of a year or an election cycle. This is the work of a generation. The movement we are watching is a symptom of a 1,500-year-old sickness. It will not be cured by one victory or one defeat. It will be outlived by those who build what it cannot destroy.
Your job is not to win. Your job is to endure, to protect, to build, and to be ready.
The practical moves above are how you do that. They are small, local, often invisible. They do not make headlines. They do not satisfy the hunger for immediate justice. But they are the only things that have ever worked.
A Final Word to Those Who Have Been Here Before
To my fellow Black Americans who have read this far: You know this story. Your ancestors survived the Middle Passage, the plantation, the Klan, Jim Crow, and a hundred smaller apocalypses. They did it by building what the fire could not reach: community, memory, faith, and an unkillable insistence on their own humanity.
That is your inheritance. That is your toolkit. That is how you outlast this too.
The Roman option is exhausted—for now. The Germanic tribe is ascendant—for now. But you have always lived in the gap between the promise and the practice. You have always navigated systems not built for you. You have always found ways to survive, to resist, to build, to love, to persist.
This moment is not the end of that story. It is another chapter.
The house is burning. But you are not the house. You are the hands that will build what comes next.
---
Start where you are. Use what you have. Do what you can.
That has always been enough.
Comments
Post a Comment